Sarah Flint Shoes Review: My Honest Take on Every Pair I Own

You all know my love for Italy runs deep, so when Sarah Flint reached out to me on Instagram about being a brand ambassador for luxury shoes that are handcrafted in Italy, it was a no brainer.

That was years ago, and I’ve since worn twelve pairs of Sarah Flint shoes (plus their beautiful Hofburg Tea Scarf) through every season. This post is my full, honest breakdown of every pair, including fit, comfort, sizing, and whether I think each one is worth the investment. If you’re looking for styling ideas specifically, I’ve also got a summer sandals guide and a winter boots and shoes edit, but everything you need to decide if Sarah Flint is right for you is below.

Please note: I received gifted pairs of shoes, and I now use ShopMy affiliate links, meaning I may receive a commission if you purchase through the links below. All opinions are my own.

Quick Verdict: Are Sarah Flint Shoes Worth It?

If you want the short answer before the deep dive: yes. Sarah Flint shoes are an investment, but I can honestly say I’ve never worn a more comfortable shoe. A few things that consistently stand out across every pair I own:

• The arch support and extra footbed padding (usually 3-6mm) make these wearable for hours on end
• They’re handcrafted in Italy and it shows in the leather quality and construction
• Comfort holds up whether it’s a flat, a wedge, or a pointed-toe pump
• They’re expensive, so I’d treat them as a cost-per-wear investment rather than an impulse buy

Sarah Flint Sizing and Fit: What to Know Before You Buy

This is the question I get asked more than anything else. In general, I find Sarah Flint runs true to size. I wear my normal size across most styles. That said, a few things are worth knowing before you order:

• Booties and some closed styles can run a little snug. If you have a wider foot or extra room in the toe box matters to you, sizing up a half size is a safe bet for those styles.
• The padding takes up a little room. Because there’s real footbed padding (a good thing for comfort), closed-toe styles can feel slightly snugger out of the box than a shoe with no cushioning. This typically softens with a few wears.
• Returns and exchanges go through Sarah Flint directly. I’d recommend checking their current return policy on their site before you order, since policies can be updated. But in my experience, and based on readers who’ve reached out to me, exchanges for sizing issues have been accommodated.

If you’re unsure between two sizes on a specific style, I always recommend checking the “Fit Notes” on that shoe’s product page. Sarah Flint includes style-specific sizing guidance that’s worth reading before you buy.

Perfect Block Sandal 30 in Sand Calf

The Perfect Block Sandal 30 in Sand Calf was my first Sarah Flint shoe, and it’s one I still wear often years later. It goes with anything. I’ve styled it with jeans and a band tee for a night out, summer dresses, and even a laid-back gala. The 6mm footbed of extra padding and arch support makes it one of the most comfortable sandals I own, block heel included. This was my go-to date night shoe all summer long.

Perfect Pump 100 in Black Calf

I’m not usually one to reach for pumps, but I had to try the Perfect Pump 100, mainly because Lady Gaga owns a pair. I love this shoe because you can style it with a pantsuit, a little black dress, or dress up a pair of jeans. If you struggle to walk in a skinny heel (I’m right there with you), the block heel styles on this list are the way to go. But if a high heel is your thing, this one is beautiful and surprisingly wearable thanks to the padding.

The Natalie in Saddle Vachetta

The Natalie might be the most versatile shoe on this entire list, which is probably why I own it in multiple colors. Two words to describe it: feminine and classy. I could wear it all day with a fall dress or a pair of jeans, and the sophisticated bow detail makes it feel a little more special than a basic flat.

The Natalie in Black Vachetta is my easiest throw-on-in-the-morning shoe. It works for the office or a walk downtown and dresses up or down for pretty much any occasion. The Natalie in Saddle Vachetta has extra padding to keep you comfortable and makes an effortless statement. The Natalie in Sand Calf or Black Vachetta is my go-to for work. I can spend hours on my feet at an event and still look stylishly professional.

Perfect Mirjana Wedge 50 in Saddle Vachetta and Raffia

The Perfect Mirjana Wedge 50 is one of my more recent additions, and like the Natalie, I love the bow detail. It’s easy to walk in, which isn’t always a given with a wedge, and it’s perfect for summer nights and sundresses.

Arabesque Slide in Two-Tone Camel Nappa

The Arabesque Slide quickly became my summer go-to. It’s the easiest shoe to throw on when you’re running out the door, and the Two-Tone Camel Nappa color makes it stand out from every other summer sandal in my closet.

Grear Sandal in Gold Calf

My mom and I both own a pair of the Grear sandals. These were constructed on the Amalfi Coast, and the mixed silver and gold detailing means they pair with just about everything you own. It’s a special-occasion sandal that still feels wearable. They are harder to break in at first, but once you wear them a few times, they’ll be the most comfortable pair of shoes you own. Plus, you’ll get so many compliments!

Perfect Block Sandal 60 in Espresso Croc Embossed Calf

I own two pairs of Perfect Block Sandals, the Sand Calf above, and this one in espresso croc-embossed calf, which might be my all-time favorite of the two. It features the same ample arch support as the original, plus adjustable ankle straps with hidden elastic and a lightweight block heel that makes it easy to wear all day.

Perfect Emma in Espresso Suede

The Perfect Emma is perhaps one of Sarah Flint’s classiest styles. The tortoise printed patent leather heel pairs beautifully with the triple-dyed Italian suede, and with 6mm of extra footbed padding, it’s a shoe you can sashay in all day long.

Alexandra 50 Boots in Black Stretch Suede

The Alexandra 50 is a knee-high boot with the same tortoise-print, patent-leather block heel as the Perfect Emma. It’s fabulous, sophisticated, and comfortable, with a functional interior half zipper that makes it easy to get on and off. I’d call these the boots of the season, hands down. For more on how I style these for winter, check out my Sarah Flint boots and winter shoes edit.

Rosie Loafer in Black Suede

Perfect for everyday wear, the Rosie is a low-heeled loafer that elevates any casual outfit. I’ve paired mine with jeans, skirts, and dress pants. It’s versatile, comfy, and one of the easiest shoes on this list to reach for on a busy day.

Perfect Round Toe Pump 70 in Cognac Suede

The Perfect Round Toe Pump 70 is truly, well, perfect, and the cognac suede screams fall and winter. It can be dressed up or down, though my go-to is pairing it with a sweater and jeans for a little pop of polish. With an expanded toe box and anatomical arch support, this is one I could wear all day long without complaint.

Perfect Zip Bootie 70 in Espresso Crosta

I love the suede on the Perfect Zip Bootie 70. It’s a comfortable boot and gives me an option for when I don’t want to wear the knee-high Alexandra 50. It’s great for the transition into fall, and it works just as well as a winter staple. Like the rest of Sarah Flint’s Perfect Collection, it comes with arch support, a roomier toe box, and a cushioned insole, and the double-zip closure makes it one of the easiest boots on this list to get on and off.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sarah Flint Shoes

Do Sarah Flint shoes run true to size?
In my experience, yes, for most styles, though some booties and closed-toe styles can run slightly snug. If you’re between sizes or have a wider foot, sizing up a half size is a safe bet. Always check the style-specific Fit Notes on the product page before ordering.

What is Sarah Flint’s return policy?
Return and exchange policies are handled directly through Sarah Flint, so I’d recommend checking their current policy on sarahflint.com before you order, since it can change. In my experience and from reader feedback, sizing exchanges have generally been accommodated.

Are Sarah Flint shoes worth the money?
Yes, I consider them an investment shoe. Between the arch support, the padding, and the Italian craftsmanship, I’ve gotten years of wear out of every pair I own, which brings the cost-per-wear down significantly over time.

How comfortable are Sarah Flint shoes for all-day wear?
Extremely comfortable. Every pair I own has real footbed padding (typically 3- 6 mm) and arch support, which makes a noticeable difference whether I’m in a flat, a wedge, or a heel. I’ve worn these for full days on my feet without the discomfort I’d expect from a dressier shoe.

Where can I buy Sarah Flint shoes?
Directly through sarahflint.com or through my linked styles above.